Services
Independent peer review of geothermal designs
A second set of expert eyes on a geothermal design before it goes to bid is cheap insurance. Carda Geothermal Engineering reviews ground loop and source-side designs prepared by others and issues clear, prioritized findings, catching undersized borefields, oversized ones, pipe sizing problems and missing specifications while they're still easy to fix.
What we check
- Load basis: are peak and annual loads realistic and correctly applied?
- Borefield length, depth, spacing and long-term ground temperature trend
- Hybrid assumptions and supplemental equipment sizing
- Header and circuit pipe sizing, flow balance and pumping energy
- Ability to flush and purge the system at the required velocity
- Pipe, grout and heat-transfer fluid specifications
- Pressure testing, TC testing and installation requirements in the specs
- Constructability and value engineering opportunities
- Conformance with CSA/ANSI/IGSHPA C448 and ASHRAE methods
Who it's for
- Owners who want confidence before committing to construction
- Engineers of record who want an independent check of a loop design from a contractor or another consultant
- Contractors evaluating a bid design
- Incentive program administrators, utilities and lenders who need third-party review
Deliverables
A written review memorandum with findings ranked by impact, marked-up drawings where useful, and a back-check of the revised design.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a peer review take?
It depends on project size and the completeness of the documents. A typical review is scheduled at proposal stage so it fits your bid or permit timeline.
Will a peer review delay my project?
Usually the opposite. Problems found on paper are faster and cheaper to fix than problems found in the field.
Can a peer review reduce cost?
Often. Overly conservative borefields, oversized pumps and unnecessary hybrid equipment are common findings.
Related services
Ground Loop Design
Borefield sizing, headers, pipe sizing calculations, details and specifications for closed-loop ground heat exchangers.
Learn moreMEP Design Review
A review of the heat pumps, piping, pumps and fluid for what they do to the ground loop.
Learn moreOwner's Rep Guidance
Feasibility, procurement and technical oversight on the owner's side of the table.
Learn moreHave a geothermal project in planning, design or trouble?
Send a few details about your project and what you need. You'll get a reply within one business day.